Differences between C++ and C# AWS GameLift Server SDK

Hi!

I am working on porting AWS GameLift Server SDK to Rust. As a reference, I use the official AWS GameLift Server SDKs - C++ and C# version. As a 3rd party implementation, I also use Javascript implementation.

But I found one interesting difference between C++ and C# SDKs - how they connect to the AWS GameLift Server. C++ version creates 2 WebSocket connection (actually, it’s a socket.io connection) on localhost:5757; C# version creates 1 WebSocket connection on localhost:5759 and sends HTTP requests to localhost:5758.

Honestly, I like the C# design here since the implementation of request-response pattern over WebSocket in C++ and JS SDKs is a little bit ugly (IMHO).

My question is: is it safe for me in my custom SDK use C# approach instead of C++? Because other custom implementation like JS uses only raw websockets without any HTTP. Who knows, maybe using HTTP is strictly restricted to the official SDK…

So if anyone has any information about that - please share :slight_smile:

Hey zamazan4ik,

The idea behind the C# SDK update is that the socket.io library was creating a lot of issues for us (e.g. race condition), particularly in C#, so we have updated the C# architecture to get rid of socket.io, and while doing so, also updated it to use a lightweight and full-duplex protocol with open-source libraries in a large variety of languages (C#, C++, Java, JS being the required ones to support). Eventually, Websocket over HTTP was chosen due to the "variety of language’ requirement; we have also considered using plain socket but eventually decided against it due to it not being available in open-source libraries of all aforementioned languages.

So, you can implement with either plain socket or websocket. There is no preference on the gamelift’s side. Though, GameLift has only tested with websocket officially, so you could potentially have better support when going that route.

Thanks for the information! I will choose C# SDK approach for the Rust version of the SDK. HTTP + WebSocket is more preferrable for me than Socket.io (actually I don’t like the idea of using Socket.io here). If you have any influence on AWS Docs team, will be awesome, if you put the information about the differences between SDKs somehwere in AWS GameLift Server SDKs documentation.

Thanks!

Thanks, I have submitted a request to update the doc. Someone from GameLift will reply to this thread once the update is completed.

GLIFT-14761

1 Like

Btw, is there any additional form to post any feedback to the AWS GameLift team? E.g. about publishing officially Protobuf scheme as a part of the SDK? Now only unofficial reverse-engineered version is available and that’s too inconvenient to use

We do have a backlog task to open source the SDK on Github, though I cannot guarantee when that would be. However, here is the protobuf scheme to unblock you: GameLift sdk.proto - Pastebin.com

1 Like

Thanks! Honestly few hours ago I just reverse-engineered the latest scheme: GitHub - ZaMaZaN4iK/GameLift-Server-Protobuf: Unofficial Protobuf files for GameLift Server :slight_smile:

But thanks a lot! Would be awesome, if you be able to somehow to publish updated schema with every SDK release.

1 Like

@JamesM_Aws any chance you can provide the proto definition for the Realtime SDK as well? I also asked on repost

@gearstache Sure, here they are

Thanks! Exactly what I needed

Are you making a custom client SDK? :slight_smile:

Yes, I was attempting to port to Java/Kotlin. Do you happen to know of an existing port? If not, will there be any issues with me publishing on github when I’m done?

@gearstache as far as I know, there is no existing Java/Kotlin port yet. So you need to implement it.

You can easily publish it to GitHub without any issues. Community already done some ports to other languages like JS, Go, Rust.

@gearstache Have you had any luck with the client port to Java/Kotlin? I want to do something similar, but I am new to Websocket connections, and was looking for anyone who had any hints on how to get going with creating communication to the GameLift service via Java. If you are willing to share anything you have I would love to take a look. Thanks. And good luck!

Hi @jackiswise, yes I’ve got a Kotlin port worked out, at least as far as unsecured communication goes. I haven’t tried to port the TLS connection options. Let me spend some time tidying things up this weekend and try to get what I’ve finished up on Github. I’ll respond here when done

1 Like

@jackiswise I’ve got everything but DTLS (secure UDP) working. You can develop against an insecure server, and you can also develop against a secure server, as long as the server does not send any Fast (UDP) messages to the client.

Thank you. I am very interested in this.